Lobster Thermidor

Lobster thermidor is a dish created by stuffing an empty lobster tail with sautéed lobster meat that is cooked with butter, a light wine (often sherry), and cream. The resulting sauce is stuffed into a lobster shell then topped with either a cheese, mushrooms or combination of vegetables before being placed under an open flame or broiled. The dish originated in Europe but was popularized in the US in the mid-20th century. Perhaps the most prominent reference to Lobster Thermidor is in the movie Citizen Kane;[1] while never shown, is it used as an example of early 20th century Northeastern haute cuisine. While present in older American cookbooks, the preparation is no longer widely-known. It is related to Lobster Newberg, another lobster tail recipe commonly presented in older Northeastern-themed cookbooks.

Medium
🥐 French
Ingredients
Everything you'll need to make this recipe
1

½ lb (225 g) cooked lobster meat, preferably from the tail; see notes

2

1 cleaned lobster tail shell

3

3 tablespoons butter or margarine

4

1 cup (240 ml) heavy cream

5

2 egg yolks

6

½ cup (120 ml) sherry or brandy

7

½ cup (120 g) grated gruyere or mozzarella cheese

8

Salt

9

Freshly-ground black pepper

Instructions
Step-by-step guide to making this recipe
1

In a serving bowl, mix together egg yolks and cream, then set aside for later use.

2

In a saucepan large enough to accommodate everything, warm the butter over low heat until it melts.

3

Add the cooked lobster meat and wine to the butter, then sauté over medium-high heat for about 2–3 minutes, or until the meat is warmed through and the wine has been mostly absorbed.

2–3 minutes

4

Slowly add the cream and egg mixture, stirring all the time to ensure that the sauce is evenly mixed.

5

When the sauce has thickened remove from heat.

6

Set oven to broil or prepare an open flame.

7

Carefully stuff the empty lobster tail with the filling.

8

Top the filling with the grated cheese, salt, and pepper.

9

Place the filled shell underneath the open flame and broil for 3–8 minutes, or until the cheese melts and turns a golden brown.

3–8 minutes

10

Remove from the oven, and serve on a warmed plate with garnish and appropriate accompaniments.

Notes
  • Cooking and shelling a fresh lobster can be a time consuming process, so frozen or pre-shelled tail meat is often used as a substitute. If you would like to prepare your own lobster meat, refer to the recipe for boiled lobster.
  • While the base preparation of Lobster Thermidor often remains the same, the type of wine or cheese used, or the way that the lobster is cooked differs.
  • Some preparations include utilizing the broth generated from cooking the lobster with carrots, celery, tarragon, and wine as an additional ingredient to thicken the sauce of cream and sherry.